This post is due to a friend of mine asking me to post something. He did ask that the post be heretical; maybe next time.
Jesus is speaking to us. He is speaking to you and he is speaking to me. This teaching, in the Sermon on the Mount, is delivered to those who had already decided to follow him. It is a warning. Scripture is full of contradictions. At one point in Matthew’s Gospel he tells us, “For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light.” (Matt 11.30) If I am to believe the commentaries, the term ‘yoke’ refers to the body of teachings of a Rabbi. Yet, in this passage we are told that gate is narrow and the path is difficult to find. To use this verse as the self-congratulatory boast that we have made it, misses the point.
Yes, this is a warning. In the following verses Jesus tells us that despite of all that we might have done “in his name” that we never knew him. This caution is for us to be mindful of how we live our faith. I think it was delivered in the hyperbolic style of Rabbis at the time. (Think televangelists) But, was it really hyperbole? One only has to consider the devastation that has been wrought in the name of Jesus to understand this warning. The broad path does lead to destruction. The broad path is so often religion itself. We so often ignore the call to self-examination that is the core of this warning.
With school over for the time being, I have more time to play with Jinks and watch YouTube videos. And nestled between videos of pop music and political commentary, I watch people teaching on our faith. Some of them are good, some are not so good, and then there are those that are cringe worthy. (The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.) I also watch the occasional documentary of history and archeology.
Through all this I have found a number of teachers that I think are worth taking the time to watch. One of them particularly so. In using the idea of our life of faith being a path he has identifies two extremes. On one side would be Progressive Christianity and deconstructionism. On the other side lies Conservative Christianity and tradition. He is talking about these being taken to EXTREMES. He also states that he sees value in both and agrees with some of the things each side presents. (Maybe the narrow path?) In his teachings he has become quite popular. Some have likened him to Timothy Keller.
Thus the stage is set for his critics to become vocal. It is surprising that there are those who would take the time to criticize him. To make a video that focuses on how this teacher is wrong, misreads scripture, and misquotes other authors is weird. It is also weird that often these critiques misquotes him and misreads scripture. Also, they use earlier teachings of him to dismiss what he has to say. (It is not like as we grow in faith our understanding changes.) It moves beyond weird when the critique becomes that this man is not a Christian and that he is teaching heresy. I think we need to judge what is taught to us and discern that which we find useful and that which we don’t. Even with the most cringe worthy of teachers I find ideas that are useful. Too often the measure of the truth and accuracy of what this man teaches is whether his doctrine aligns with the critic’s own theology.
To give those who have provided such critiques the benefit of the doubt, perhaps they are doing so to warn others of this apostate hypocrite. Paul, the apostle, warned of those teaching other Gospels. And I get the impulse to attack those who we disagree with vehemently. Added to this are a few videos that I have watched that teach us what we have to believe in order for us to be a Christian. It is more than Jesus came to walk amongst us teaching, died on the Cross, and then was raised from the dead. Even within the Crucifixion and Resurrection there is a specific view that is considered “true.” This is despite that there are various perspectives of what occurred on Golgotha.
To be honest I watch these videos with a bias. My theology has always been “left of centre.” DM to ask about my cat’s relationship with God. I am little guarded against others “critiquing” my faith. To continue to be honest, there are those who I question the validity of their faith. I am doing better with not condemning them. Here is the crux of the matter. We do need to consider the teachings of others. I would include the person that is sitting next to you as offering an understanding of the Gospel. We also need to do more than just see if what they are teaching fits within our understanding. None of us have the one and only correct understanding of what it means to follow the teachings of Jesus.
We are told that the gate is narrow and the path difficult to find. We are not called to congratulate ourselves that we have made it! In fact all through the New Testament we are cautioned to never consider that we have arrived. If we are to mature in our faith we need to keep our focus on whether we are following Christ. This includes considering the perspectives of others.
That is not to say that there are not heresies. There are! Not as many as we think. My point, and you knew I would eventually get around to it, is this. My faith and my focus is on whether I am following Jesus. (This is more than following his Facebook page and Twitter feed.) When I bump against those who believe and practice their faith differently, I am to be humble in my approach. I am to quietly state how I believe and follow the teachings. To engage in arguing and attacking them leads me away from the path that I am called to walk.
The gate is narrow. May it be opened for you. The path is narrow. May it be revealed to you. More than that may you come to know “the breadth and length and height and depth” of God’s love for you.